*No oxygen equals major Bouchie Lake fish kill*
October 3, 2008
By Andrea Johnson
Thousands of rainbow trout suffocate in anoxic water in two days
Martin Eastman slowly guides his boat along the west side of Bouchie Lake towards Purcer Creek.
In the distance his two passengers are looking for fins of rainbow trout above the shallow water as they try to swim upstream.
As we move closer on a sunny fall Monday afternoon, some are jumping above the water gasping for air.
They want to breathe, but they can’t.
They’re suffocating.
There’s no oxygen.
As we get closer, the trout, some as big as five pounds, others as small as fry are floating on top of the water. Others have sunk to the bottom of the clear lake.
They’re dead.
Eastman and his wife Anna have never seen anything like it in 18 years living along the eastern shores of Bouchie Lake.
It’s never been this bad.
Martin is chair of Bouchie Lake Stewardship committee, a pro-active volunteer group that monitors the levels of the lake and keeps its eyes peeled for any problems that may arise. They’re also a liaison with the provincial Ministry of Environment.
Martin and Anna first noticed the fish kill Sunday when they received a call from a neighbour who lives along the lake.
A call to the local conservation officer led to his inspection at the public access boat launch who then called MOE.
Martin said at first it looked like only 50 fish were affected by the kill, but after a closer look around the lake, there were 2,000.
Chris Swan, an impact assessment biologist from MOE, Environmental Protection based in Williams Lake, checked it out Monday morning.
She chalks up the major kill to a combination of events.
Based on weekly readings of temperature and dissolved oxygen gathered by Bouchie Lake Stewardship group, Swan can tell that Bouchie Lake recently had a big algae bloom which died off.
The lake is also 12 C from top to bottom which means it’s turning over.
These two events resulted in the combination depletion of almost all of the dissolved oxygen in the lake. Dissolved oxygen values were around 1 milligram per litre – rainbow trout become stressed below 4-6 mg per litre of dissolved oxygen.
“The inlet creeks [such as Purcer Creek] would still be bringing in some fresh dissolved oxygen which is why the fish were schooling at the mouths of the inlet creeks,” Swan said.
Near the public boat launch on Bouchie Lake’s west side, more fish are jumping, gasping for their last breath.
They’ll sink to the bottom, decay and expand then rise to the surface.
The stewardship group measures oxygen, temperature and clarity levels once a week. Outflow and inflow levels of the creeks are measured twice each week.
“There’s not too much change between now and last week,” Martin said.
“But in spring it was .5 per metre [high] and in fall it was .32 per metre. It’s down quite a bit. We have a weir on the lake to keep it a certain point.”
In 2000, a sediment core was taken from the bottom of Bouchie Lake. The core contained a record of the past 500 years of sediment deposition on its bottom. The types of bottom-dwelling insects in the core told biologists that for 450 years, Bouchie Lake was a well-oxygenated lake.
“In 1950, things began to change to a less-oxygenated bottom,” Swan said.
“By the 1970s, a dramatic shift towards anoxic (no dissolved oxygen) bottom waters had taken place. This timing corresponds to increased human activity in the watershed.”
The anoxic water, Swan said, is blamed on increased nutrients in the form of nitrogen and phosphorus, the main components of fertilizer.
That occurs as a result of decay of plants, both aquatic and algae, which have blossomed from increased nutrients.
“In most of the lakes in our region, phosphorus is the limiting factor – when all the phosphorus is taken up by the plants, they won’t continue to grow even if there is still nitrogen present,” Swan said.
Phosphorus is found naturally in soils, plants and plant eaters as well as in man-made concentrated forms such as fertilizer and soaps. In Bouchie Lake, the watershed and internal loading contribute to increased phosphorus.
Swan said for the watershed draining into the lake, contributing factors can include exposed soils (roads, ditches and trampled banks) draining into the two inlet creeks and the lake; poor riparian conditions, manure runoff, fertilizer use, septic systems and burning of wood.
Internal loading is a process where the lake is fertilized from within.
When phosphorus is washed down into the lake and dissolved oxygen is present, it settles to the bottom and is bound to the sediment. As aquatic plants and algae die off, fall to the bottom and begin to rot, the oxygen is used up. When there is no oxygen the phosphorus is released from the sediment back into the lower water. In shallow lakes this phosphorus-loaded bottom water is mixed into the water column when the lake turns over. It happens to Bouchie Lake in spring, late summer and fall.
“All lakes are different,” Swan said.
“Even the same lake is different from year to year. This fall had the perfect combination of weather and nutrients for a fish kill.
“Further fish kills cannot be predicted with certainty but Bouchie Lake is at risk for this happening again.”
Bouchie Lake Stewardship committee tries to inform people the best practices to preserve the 9-metre deep, 129-ha wide lake and the watershed surrounding it.
That may mean asking residents to aerate lawns instead of fertilizing them and using one of two kinds of dishwashing soap that is phosphate-free.
Swan said to lower the risk of another fish kill, serious work must be done to improve the watershed and clean up the nutrient loading running into the lake.
“Otherwise, any in-lake restoration will be long term and more expensive.
“Putting a Band-Aid on the visual problem doesn’t take care of the underlying cause.
“Everyone in the watershed must play a role in reducing phosphorus loading if there is any hope of reducing the risk of further fish kills and continued algae blooms on Bouchie Lake.”
The only potential option for Bouchie Lake, she said, is aeration.
However, she warned it’s only a potential option because details such as equipment purchase, installation, operation costs and liability/insurance and affects on the ecosystem still need to be explored.
“The lake may have clearer water but it could be a trade-off between less algae blooms but considerably more aquatic plants,” she said.
“If there was no money to run the aerators then the same problems would return.”
As for dredging the bottom of the lake, it is very site specific and costly.
Dredging lakes such as Bouchie Lake where the bottom water smells like sulfur or rotten eggs is not favourable, Swan said.
“When the sulfur-smelling sediment mixes with rain water and air, sulfuric acid is produced. These piles have toxic run-off which must be contained and treated.
“[Again], if watershed clean up isn’t done, then the in-lake problems would come back over time.”
Department of Fisheries and Oceans will do further investigative work in October to determine if all species of fish were affected and to what extent.
As for Martin and Anna Eastman, they’ll continue to enjoy the lake.
Only in the last couple of years has the lake become popular with anglers and is regularly stocked with trout.
It’s also become a haven for bird watchers who enjoy watching American white pelicans and blue herons amongst the freshwater otters.
http://www.bclocalnews.com/news/30341854.html |